PLASTIC SURGERY UNDER CHALLENGING CONDITIONS
Plastic surgery under challenging conditions means practising this specialty under difficult circumstances. The environment in which the surgery has to be performed may be unfamiliar and challenging; the working conditions may be poor; the disorders encountered may be far removed from the conditions seen in one’s home country; and the range of procedures to be performed may be vast (hand surgery, burn scar revision, orthopaedics and traumatology, maxillofacial surgery, etc.)
This article is addressed to colleagues going on their first mission, and wondering what is in store for them. What disorders will they need to manage? Under what conditions will surgery have to be performed? Which techniques should one use? What instruments should one take with one on the trip? – These are but some of the many questions that arise.
We shall try to answer these questions simply, by suggesting solutions that we have found on mission trips. You should feel free to write up these ideas yourself, and to improve on the suggestions made in this article. We have tried to record, briefly, what we have learnt on a number of missions, to such countries as the Congo, Togo, Benin, Nigeria, and Armenia.
From a retrospective analysis of 100 patients operated on during such missions, we have distilled six surgical techniques that have allowed us to treat 86% of these patients. The six techniques are described in this article, together with practical management principles.
Plastic
surgery under challenging conditions – what is it?
Plastic
surgery is a well-defined surgical specialty, which encompasses
reconstructive surgery, purely plastic surgery, as well as cosmetic
(aesthetic) procedures. Thus, breast reconstruction after mastectomy for
breast cancer is reconstructive surgery. The surgical treatment of breast
hypertrophy comes under the heading of plastic surgery, since it modifies the
shape of the breast. A reconstructed breast must, however, also have a nice
shape and look good. Plastic surgery means reconstruction to give an
aesthetically pleasing result. Looks and function are closely interrelated
– something that looks good may, for this reason alone, work better; and
something that works should also look good.
In Europe,
different departments of plastic surgery have different approaches to cater
for different conditions. Thus, a department that treats injuries of the hand
will be concerned mainly with plastic surgery of the hand and with
microsurgery. A burns unit will specialize in skin grafts and the treatment of
burn scars, and will concern itself with such techniques as skin expansion.
Plastic
surgery under challenging conditions means practising reconstructive
surgery under difficult circumstances. The term commonly used nowadays is
"humanitarian plastic surgery". We have opted for the phrase
"under challenging conditions", since it is more general, and more
realistic. "Humanitarian" may have a somewhat self-important
connotation – suggesting the great white doctor come to perform great white
surgery.
Also, anything
a doctor does should be humanitarian, regardless of where in the world the
treatment is being provided. There is no need for a surgeon to go on a mission
in order to do humanitarian work. Humanitarian plastic surgery is being
performed in France, day in, day out, by plastic surgeons. We can be humane
without engaging in "humanitarian" work. Oddly, though, it is also
possible to do engage in a humanitarian exercise without being humane: some
"volunteers" appear to see humanitarian work as an opportunity to
travel, rather than as an opportunity to help human beings in distress.
Plastic
surgery under challenging conditions has several distinguishing features.
- It is
practised in an unfamiliar and demanding environment.
- The
facilities for surgery tend to be poor.
- The disorders
encountered are different from the ones seen at home.
- The surgeon
must be conversant with all aspects of plastic surgery (hand surgery, the
treatment of burns and their sequelae, trauma, maxillofacial surgery, etc.).
- The
environment will be unfamiliar, because the surgical mission goes abroad,
to unfamiliar countries with health care systems that differ from the one at
home (dispensaries and similar structures). Practising surgery also involves
working in teams that may comprise very different personalities. Surgeons may
belong to diametrically opposed "schools" of surgery, and hold very
different views from their team-mates. Also, the climate will be different, as
will the conditions of daily living.
- The
working conditions may be poor, both in terms of the facilities provided
(poorly functioning operating theatres, frequent power cuts, extremely
unreliable sterility, etc.) and in terms of the administrative and
patient-care infrastructure (no patient appointments, wrong diagnoses,
patients unprepared for surgery, dressings not done, etc.).
- The
conditions encountered will be unusual; some will be seen at an advanced
stage not normally encountered back home. Thus, noma (cancrum oris) and Buruli
ulcers are not seen in Europe. Patients in Europe may have burn scars, but
rarely to the extent seen on missions. Congenital or tumour-related
malformations tend to be seen at very advanced stages.
- The
plastic surgeon must be able to turn his or her hand to very different aspects
of the specialty: reconstructive hand surgery, the surgical management of
burns and burn scars, the repair of congenital malformations of the face,
maxillofacial reconstruction of lesions caused by certain tropical diseases,
surgery to restore limb function, closure of the abdominal wall after the
removal of massive tumours, etc.
Even when
performed for "humanitarian" reasons, plastic surgery must address
the aesthetic dimension. Many surgeons still feel that "humanitarian
aesthetic surgery" is a contradiction in terms. How can one envisage
cosmetic surgery when the object of the mission is to meet the most basic
demands for surgery? Aesthetic surgery is still considered as something
undertaken to prettify patients who are not really ill, as opposed to the
"real" surgery provided by the "humanitarian" surgeon, who
is there to help those in actual need of surgery.
Let us
remember, though, that it is not for us to decide what is and what is not
important to a given patient. We are here to meet the patient’s demand,
regardless of the nature of, and the background to, this demand. It may,
undoubtedly, be more ego-boosting for a surgeon to say that, but for his
operation, the patient would have been left with a functional deficit;
however, the ultimate objective of surgery should be the satisfaction of the
patient. And if something that looks good is more likely to function better,
then why not ensure that a good functional result is also aesthetically
pleasing? Regardless of the countries visited, the patients we have
encountered during our missions have taught us that, to them, the cosmetic
result was as important as the functional outcome, or that the two aspects
were indissociable.
On one mission,
we came across a young Armenian girl who had suffered terrible burns of the
back of her hand. She had a huge hypertrophic scar, which did not, however,
interfere with function in a major way. Through a translator, we explained to
her that nothing should be done, and that, if the scar were to be removed, the
skin on the back of her hand would be so tight that she would not be able to
clench her fist. Our explanation was clear, and was understood by the
translator and by the patient. Next day, the girl came to our clinic. She
wanted to have the scar removed, and explained that she fully understood why
we were against such an operation, but that she would rather have a
better-looking hand than be able to move her fingers properly.
There was also
a cosmetic consideration in the reconstruction of the elbow of a young man in
Benin , who had had had a Buruli ulcer. Buruli ulcers (caused by Mycobacterium
ulcerans ) rank third, after tuberculosis and leprosy, among the
mycobacterial infections seen in otherwise healthy subjects. The majority of
the patients are women and children who live in rural areas, close to
waterways or wetlands. Buruli ulcers are a widespread condition in the swampy
tropical and subtropical regions of Africa (around the Gulf of Guinea ), in
Latin America , Asia , and the western Pacific. The condition affects mainly
the limbs; it gradually and painlessly destroys the skin and the subcutaneous
tissue, and may burrow deeper yet. At the post-ulcerative stage, there will be
huge retracted fibrous scars, with many associated deformities.
The young man
from Benin presented with one of these deformities. His right elbow was
contracted, with extensive fibrosis, especially over the anterior aspect. We
performed a wide resection, and managed to release the elbow completely. The
defect was covered by a pedicled myocutaneous latissimus dorsi flap. Elbow
mobility was excellent, and the postoperative course was uneventful. We were
happy to have restored function to the patient’s elbow, since, with a
working elbow, the young man would be able to work in the fields, and,
consequently, think of having a family. We were very aware of this association
between the functional and the expected social outcome.
However, the
flap was still a bit bulky, and did not look very attractive. We explained to
the patient that the flap would get thinner by and by. But how does one get
the concept of secondary muscle atrophy across? Also, Buruli ulcers are
painless. Following surgery, the patient obviously had some pain. We had
performed a successful operation, but in the patient's eyes we had done more
harm than good.
In noma, the
repair of some of the facial mutilations also serves an – often tacit –
cosmetic purpose, even though the highly sophisticated techniques employed are
designed for reconstruction. Noma, also known as cancrum oris, is an infective
ulcerative and necrotic gingivostomatitis which, nowadays, affects mainly
African children (in the so-called noma belt of Africa ). Malnutrition, poor
oral hygiene, and a variety of systemic diseases are risk factors. Mortality
has been greatly diminished by the use of antibiotics and proper nutrition. At
the postulcerative stage, the patients are left with major orofacial
disfigurement.
I vividly
remeber a young girl from Togo , who came to us accompanied by some nuns from
northern Nigeria . She had been living alone, outside her village, and had
been raped repeatedly. Her face was terribly disfigured by noma, with a huge,
foul-smelling cleft from the corner of the mouth right up to the temporal
region. The nuns had been unable to anything for her, so they had decided to
bring her to us.
Basically,
there was nothing wrong with her physiologically or in terms of laboratory
parameters. She just could not chew. She was getting enough nutrition from
(manioc-based) liquid feeds, and did not appear to have any nutritional
deficiencies. So why did we operate on her? To restore function, that's why.
To reconstruct her face, that's also why. We think that she was happy to be
able to close her mouth a bit more, and to move her jaw, however little. Above
all, we think that she was happy to have a face again that might no longer
need to be hidden behind a veil. In more than one way, she was healed – and
that was cause for happiness.
These examples
prompted us to think about the true purpose of surgical missions under
challenging conditions. Plastic surgery is only one modality, in a vast array
of treatment approaches. Healing, function – those are the results that
satisfy us surgeons. But what about pain relief? What about the fact that this
girl, with her new-found face, was no longer being raped? Who can say what
"healing" really means?
Humanitarian
aesthetic surgery has taught us that cosmesis is essential for repair, and
that there is no need for trying to justify cosmesis by saying that it is a
byproduct of reconstruction: cosmesis is an integral part of reconstruction.
Reparing a cleft lip in a little Asian girl could be seen as reconstructive
surgery, or as aesthetic surgery. One might say that it is reconstructive
surgery, because that is more " significant ", or because it
involves reconstruction of the muscles of the lip. The little girl might want
a prettier, a more cosmetically appealing lip. So that would make cleft-lip
repair an aesthetic procedure. However, the "why" is unimportant,
since the "how" – the technique – will be the same, and since
the surgeon will always try to achieve the best, and the most cosmetic,
result. It follows that the reason for which the surgery is performed is the
only criterion for calling a particular operation a reconstructive or an
aesthetic procedure. Once the operation has been decided upon, the execution
of the procedure will be the same. In the final resort, it is not definitions
that matter: what counts is that the little Asian girl will be happy, and, as
we hope, will be "pretty" happy.
In practical
terms, and however paradoxical it may sound, we have learnt not to do
aesthetic surgery, but to do surgery with a view to achieving an aesthetic
result, even when working on a so-called humanitarian mission.
Plastic
surgery under challenging conditions – why do it?
Because there
is a demand, and we are able to offer something to meet this demand. We might
ask ourselves whether the situation has been demand-driven, or whether the
offer has generated the demand. We think that the disease conditions seen in
those countries have been there for a very long time, and did not suddenly
occur when surgery became available.
Reconstructive
surgery, on the other hand, is very old, since facial reconstruction is
described in papyri dating from several centuries B.C. Thus the Edwin Smith
Papyrus contains descriptions of nasal reconstructions using cheek flaps. In
those days, the punishment for adultery was having one's nose cut off. This is
why enlightened surgeons offered reconstructions using flaps fashioned from
the surrounding skin. These procedures are still in use today. This should
make us more humble in our "humanitarian" work, our
"humanity".
So why is
there so much talk, these days, of plastic surgery under challenging
conditions?
- Firstly,
because plastic surgery appears ideally suited to the management of disease
conditions found in third-world countries: congenital malformations of the
face or the limbs, skin sequelae of burns or of tropical diseases, various
tumours, functional sequelae after limb trauma, etc.
- Secondly,
because plastic surgery has, by now, become a specialty in its own right.
In the past, surgeons on humanitarian missions would apply the techniques they
were familiar with, and the nature of the surgery performed was less well
defined in terms of surgical disciplines. This does not mean that the work
done was less effective – but it was general, rather than specialized,
surgery. A surgeon would treat all comers, provided that he or she had the
necessary technique. However, as surgery became more specialized over time, so
did the humanitarian missions.
- Thirdly,
because plastic surgery is a readily "exportable" specialty. The
surgical instruments required are fairly simple and easy to carry. Skin
surgery is less susceptible to infection. The result is readily seen, and
often obeys an 'all-or-none' law: if a flap is to go necrotic, it will do so
straight away, and the situation can be remedied immediately. Patient
follow-up is reasonably easy and straightforward to manage. Techniques are
easier to teach, since what needs to be done is more readily
"visible", and hence more readily understood.
- Fourthly,
because there are voluntary teams – nurses, anaesthetists, and
surgeons – who will go on missions of this kind.
- And, lastly,
because we operate on many children during these plastic-surgery missions. It
is dreadful to think that children’s lives are blighted by disease or
disfigurement, but many think that there is no way out. Must these children
really hope in vain? Medicine can add years to the children’s lives; plastic
surgery can add life to these years. Perhaps, giving a disfigured child new
hope means giving new substance to the hopes of us surgeons.
Plastic
surgery under challenging conditions – for whom?
Reconstructive
surgery missions are organized by individual plastic surgeons or by
humanitarian organizations. Such voluntary organizations may specialize in
plastic surgery (as is the case with Interplast-France), or cover plastic
surgery as part of a wider range of projects (as is the case with UMAF
– the Union des Médecins Arméniens en France –, or Médecins du Monde).
Plastic
surgery under challenging conditions – who does it?
The
composition of the teams will vary with the mission. There may be only one
surgeon on the team, if the host facility has all the other personnel
required. Conversely, a complete team may go out, in order to ensure that it
can operate independently. Interplast-France teams usually include two
surgeons, two theatre nurses, one anaesthetist with an anaesthetic nurse, and
one liaison officer. Having two surgeons allows the team to work in two
theatres simultaneously, or to have one surgeon assisting the other in complex
operations. Also, indications can be discussed and agreed with another
surgeon, and there will be cover should one of the surgeons be taken ill or be
prevented from operating for other reasons. The addition to the team of a
liaison officer has been comparatively recent, but has proved very valuable.
The liaison officer looks after all the supplies and maintenance aspects, and
liaises with the authorities in the host country. It may be thought that
having a liaison officer is a bit of a luxury on a humanitarian mission;
however, experience has shown that time spent looking after the supplies and
maintenance side of the work, or talking with the local representatives, is
mission time well spent. It also frees the surgeon from these activities, and
allows him or her to devote that much more time to the patients.
Plastic
surgery under challenging conditions – with whom?
Any mission of
this kind involves the local patients, requires the help of local medical and
non-medical personnel, and is carried out under a local authority. Other
persons may be involved, depending on the host country.
- The
patients and their conditions
For a surgical
mission to be launched, there must be patients who ask for surgery, and local
surgeons who express the wish for such assistance. No patients, no mission –
it’s as simple as that.
The concept of
a "patient" is a European one. In our part of the world, a
"patient" is indissociable from his or her condition. In Africa, to
take that continent as an example, the patient and his or her condition are
two discrete concepts.
In Africa, the
patient belongs to a family, a village, or a tribe. Whatever he or she is
suffering from will not be seen as having come about be chance. The patient
has a story, which doctors will need to listen to. Also, the real patient may
not be the person one actually sees. The patient brought to the clinic may be
just a representative of a family, and perhaps it is the family that is
"sick".
The condition
may, indeed, concern a family or a larger community. The condition will not
have come about by chance, and it has a history attached to it. This history
will need to be understood – and yet, we have neither the time nor the
capacity to listen to it properly. There is always a "reason" for an
accident that happens to someone, or for a disease that strikes a patient. The
person concerned may have trespassed on a site where the "spirits"
dwell, or contravened the rules by eating partridge meat. In some villages,
there are sites that are out of bounds during certain hours of the day.
Offending against this rule may have been the root cause of an accident or a
disease. Some families are forbidden to eat partridge meat or pork. Again,
breaking this rule may account for the accident or the disease suffered by the
patient. There is always a reason why, and this may explain the fatalistic
attitude seen in people from that part of the world.
We are just
technicians, who repair the surface, whereas the evil may come from the
"depths" of the forests. How can one treat, with a simple skin
graft, the face of a child that is being "eaten" by his grandmother?
In Africa, the condition is not always the patient’s own, and the sick
person is not always the patient.
For these
reasons, it may be difficult to provide surgical treatment for "the
condition", and even more difficult to treat a patient that one cannot
see. It would be preposterous to claim that one can truly treat, with a skin
flap, an ill that one does not know. However, African families tend to
increasingly accept Western (so-called modern) treatments for conditions that
they have "known" for a long time. This "progress" in
their attitude will need to be matched by progress on our side: we must try to
"see" the patient, and look after the patient’s history as much as
after his or her actual condition. Above all, we must become more humble,
because the vast array of our techniques is powerless against the river gods.
We can do nothing without the help of the family, of the village chief, or the
local healer. To touch a patient’s body requires consent – and, in this
respect, the consent of the family, the "group", or the
"healer" is as important as the indication pronounced by a Western
team of surgeons. As repairers of the human body, we should stick to our last,
and let the healer do whatever is felt to be necessary in the local community.
We are doctors, and must act as such. That is how we are seen by the patients,
and that is how we can help them most efficaciously. Treating the "metaphyscial"
aspects of the patient’s condition is part of the expertise of the healer,
who will be better able to deal with the "zima" side of the
treatment. In the interest of more effective patient management, treatment
will need to be multidisciplinary – and the lead figure will not always be
the one we would imagine.
It should also
be remembered that the patients show great courage in accepting our
treatments, which, to them, may appear surprising or puzzling. Just think of
what it must be like for a little child from a small village far away, who is
taken, for the first time in his or her life, into an operating theatre.
Imagine what must go through their heads when they see an operating light
shining down on them, and all those people in their blue disguise moving about
in a complicated ritual. What must it be like for them to see the chief of
this sect, who wears the "mask" of an unknown tribe and speaks to
them in a weird dialect? This chief is called a surgeon – but what power
does he have?
The way in
which traditional local treatments are provided may appear somewhat bizarre to
us. What we must realize is that, to the patients, our way of going about
things will appear equally weird. However, in both systems the way in which
things are done is important for the effectiveness of the treatment, and,
consequently, for the patient. This is why we accept that patients should be
managed with the consent of the local authority, and with support from local
practices. The object of the exercise is to cure the patient. Little does it
matter whether this cure is brought about by a well-performed graft, or
because the evil spirits from the forest have been chased away.
Finally, let us
not forget that, until quite recently, a labial cleft was known as a
"hare-lip" in our part of the world. The image came from the
countryside, where it was thought that a woman who had a cleft baby had met an
"evil animal". The idea of a river god is no more absurd than that
of a hare that puts a spell on a woman. We feel that it is important to
respect the spiritual domain in our treatment schemes. After all, "the
spirit can heal."
- The local
doctors
Having patients
is necessary, but not sufficient. It is quite impossible to think that one
could treat patients in a country without the agreement and the assistance of
the doctors in that country. There are several reasons why that is so.
Firstly, it
would be discourteous to treat someone else’s patients without asking that
doctor’s opinion.
Secondly, it
would be difficult to go to a country without letting the local doctors know
beforehand; to treat the patients without involving the local practitioners;
and to leave without ensuring the postoperative follow-up of the patients. As
a rule, one of the first problems encountered by a mission is patient
recruitment. In order for the visiting team to have patients to treat, the
difficult cases have to be identified and selected, and this cannot be done
without the involvement of the doctors “on site”. Also, when a mission is
completed, it is vital that the local doctors can ensure the follow-up of the
patients.
Thirdly,
humanitarian missions are designed to provide an exchange of ideas and even
training; it would, therefore, make sense that everything should be done in
close cooperation with the local colleagues. One of the purposes of a mission
should be the training of our foreign colleagues in the techniques practised
by ourselves. Ideally, selected techniques should be taught, which could then
be practised by the local surgeons. This teaching function of humanitarian
missions can be provided in a variety of forms. In our experience, teaching
a limited number of more specific techniques is to be preferred; and what is
taught should be taught right there and then.
We prefer to
train the surgeons at the local facility, since that way the techniques can be
suited to the conditions encountered locally, and the correct application of
what has been taught can be monitored immediately. Being there means that one
can adapt a procedure to suit the actual conditions under which surgery has to
be practised. Thus, surgical drainage is a principle that applies, and can be
taught, anywhere in the world.
However,
conventional suction drains cannot be used in Africa, for financial reasons.
There, a more manual drainage system, involving the use of syringes, will need
to be employed. This example shows that between surgical theory and the
application of that theory there may be a gulf that only familiarity with
local conditions can bridge.
We have also
learnt to be less ambitious in the teaching of surgical techniques. In the
light of our experience, we have come to prefer one or two well-defined
techniques for the management of a well-defined condition, rather than to
teach a whole range of techniques which will be difficult to absorb and will
often be of academic rather of practical interest. The most gifted surgeon
would find it hard to learn an entire new discipline in a very short time. We
would rather teach one or two techniques that can be reliably applied to the
local patients. Thus, for the management of burn scars in the hand, we prefer
full-thickness skin grafts plus a simple flap pattern for web-space repair.
There are many highly sophisticated techniques for burn reconstruction;
however, these techniques are more difficult to teach and to apply. Skin
grafting may appear to be less glamorous, but is comparatively simple to
teach, as well as very effective – and that goes for anywhere in the world.
- The local
paramedical personnel
The teams in
the host countries are usually very kind and very dedicated. They throw
themselves into the work, and pay great attention to the nursing techniques
that we demonstrate.
However, many
of us have felt, at times, that things may appear to have been perfectly
understood when we have explained or demonstrated them, and yet, when it came
to the practical application of what had been learnt, the message obviously
had not got across. This is an important point to bear in mind, because we
have learnt from this experience that nothing must be neglected, especially
when it comes to postoperative care. Rather than ask someone else to do a
dressing, we would do it ourselves. A dressing that has been done is no
longer waiting to be done.
We have also
learnt that, on some missions, drugs and dressing materials tend to get
stolen; and that the only way to make sure that the patient gets what has been
prescribed is to literally give the medication to the patient (e.g. by
sticking the antibiotics to the patient’s skin with sticky tape, so that he
or she can take them without the need for a care-giver) or, in the case of a
child, to involve the mother. Mum is always best. Even then, things can go
awry, and I remember the occasion when what Mum was doing was well-meaning but
misguided. It happened in Togo, where we had operated on a little girl with
burn scars. After the procedure, we asked the mother to provide simple care:
just to keep washing the wounds with water, and to put on a dressing. We
trusted her implicitly, and just left her with the necessary material. Our
confidence was not misplaced, because she did exactly as she had been told.
She did wash the wounds, not once but twice daily. Unfortunately, we were
inexperienced and lacking in foresight. In Africa, the big problem is water.
Without access to a tap water, the mother had washed the wounds for several
days, using the same water day in, day out; and the wounds had become
infected. Since then, we have recommended a minimum of postoperative dressing,
so as to prevent infection as much as possible.
Wherever
mission work has taken us, we have always met some outstanding people, and
seen great skill and dedication, at the facilities and in the operating
theatres where we have worked. There was that highly skilled male nurse ...
that lovely motherly female nurse ... there has always been someone to
remember. One may not immediately find these special people, but they will be
there, and they will need to be identified, because it is they who will
provide the crucial link between the team and the patients. Similarly, we have
always come across brilliant doctors, and met outstanding surgeons who could
employ unusual but highly efficacious techniques. One can learn a lot from
one’s blood brothers.
-
Local authorities, local formalities
Missions are
usually organized under the auspices of the Department of Health of the host
country. Even where the mission is funded entirely from private donations, and
organized at a non-hospital facility, it would be politic to run it under the
auspices of the local authority. This can be useful in several ways. Visas may
be more easily obtained, local permits more readily granted, and the practice
of surgery itself made easier. The Department of Health of a third-world
country may well ask you for your certificates, and even a complete CV, before
letting you operate. That is nothing to take offence at.
To give just one example: In a country in the Indian Ocean, I was asked to
provide evidence of my registration with the French General Medical Council,
to show that I was allowed to practise; I even had to submit a photocopy of my
School Leaving Certificate. At first, I was mildly irritated by these demands,
but told myself that surely there was a good reason why the authorities were
asking for all this paperwork. In fact, some European doctors who would have
been insufficiently qualified back home have been known to use the mantle of
humanitarian missions to work, more or less legally, under the tropical sun
(Comoros); while doctors who had originally come from a third-world country
may take part in a specialized mission (Red Cross, Médecins du Monde) in
order to go “back home”, claiming expertise in a specialty that they have
not got.
Apart from the
Health Minister and his staff (which may be numerous), the manager of the
hosting hospital is a Very Important Person. It would be rude not to make
one’s obeisance to him – just as one would to the heads of the local
religious communities, the district chiefs, and all sorts of people who
represent all sorts of people. This is precisely why it is so important to
have a liaison officer as part of the team. This team member will meet the
local authorities, and save the team a lot of valuable time. Whatever one may
think, these meetings are indispensable, since they follow the rules of
courtesy in international contacts, and may help to forge links that will help
future missions.
Similarly, it
has become clear to us that there are some local “formalities” that make
humanitarian missions run more smoothly in these countries. It is not a great
secret that “presents” are always welcome. The present may be the
“extra” paid to the local customs officer to allow our surgical equipment
to be cleared more quickly. It may take the form of surgical equipment
“offered” to the hospital manager, to thank this VIP for allowing us to
operate. A present may simply be some money offered to a district chief to
allow us to set foot on his territory – etc.
We think that
respecting these local rules and institutions is a must. Without encouraging
these practices, we must live with them, since we have neither the power nor
the right to fight against them. We are only there to treat as many patients
as possible in the best possible way, while we are in the country. In order to
do this, we have to submit to the local rules. If a child needs surgery,
we’ll perform this surgery. And if, in order to do so, someone will need to
be offered a “present”, we have to comply if we can. And let’s face it:
any surgical equipment given to a hospital (even if it finishes up in
someone’s private clinic) will remain in the country, and will, thus, be a
gift to the country. There is nothing we can do to change the local
“rules”, which have existed for a long time and are part of the local
tradition.
Another thing
we have learnt, mainly in Africa, is that everything has a price, however
modest; and that everything is paid for, if only with a few pieces of fruit or
a chicken. This is perhaps a good thing. By paying something for what he or
she has received, the patient preserves some dignity – it is his or her way
of saying Thank You, and it is important for them to be able to do so. We also
know that a patient who is “involved” in his or her treatment will have
more benefit from this treatment – and that goes for patients wherever they
are.
ORGANIZATION
OF THE MISSION
Before you
go
There is a
minimum number of steps to be gone through prior to leaving on a mission trip.
The basic
requirements are that the authorities of the host country should have agreed
to receive a team from abroad, that the necessary funding should have been
provided, and that the surgical team should have been set up.
German
humanitarian mission teams have taught us the importance of a “time schedule
check list”. This is a count-down, involving several meetings, which starts
12 months prior to departure. Without necessarily insisting on such an early
start, we would recommend that preparations be started about six months ahead
of the intended departure date.
Time
schedule check list
- 6 months
before: Make up the team, check mission funding, ensure agreements with
host country have been concluded..
- 4 months
before: Team meets, list of necessary equipment (for anaesthesia and
surgery) and consumables is checked. Assign tasks: decide on who looks after
the anaesthetics, the surgical supplies; who goes to the embassy to get the
visas; etc.
- 2 months
before: Check equipment and visas. If possible, arrange for a short
pre-departure meeting.
- 1 month
before: Check flight tickets; contact airline to start negotiating excess
baggage charges. Some airlines will carry excess baggage free, as a
humanitarian gesture. If this concession is not made, try to distribute the
excess among the different team members. Some anaesthetic items (such as
opioids) may cause customs problems. Getting all the kit into the host country
may be made easier by having a local representative there on arrival. With
customs clearance “eased” in this way, we suggest you keep all “dodgy”
items with you. Secondary clearance comes under a different section of the
customs service, usually does not take place until the following day, and will
involve more difficult negotiations.
- 1 week
before: Send the parcels ahead via the airline or some other carrier
(sending things by boat is less expensive). On the foreign affairs Web site,
check the latest political situation in the country you are going to. Make the
last pre-departure appointments, and finalize your preparations.
Surgical
Check list
For the
outpatient clinic
- A book for
case notes and ball-point pen(s). Ideally, the book should allow duplicate
copies to be made. In this way, one copy can be left in the patient’s
charts, as a permanent record of your work on the mission.
- A standard
and/or a Polaroid camera, for taking snapshots in the clinic, to be stapled to
the case notes.
A polaroïd
has several advantages:
- It allows
patients to be recognized subsequently. People in other countries “all
look alike”. In northern Nigeria, one noma case looks like any other noma
case, especially when the children are of the same age and from the same
tribe.
- It allows the
true extent of the lesions to be assessed. This makes for more accurate
planning of operating time at the team conference the night before the
operation. In the outpatient clinic, one tends to get carried away by
one’s enthusiasm for surgery and the thrill of having discovered an
interesting case; this does not allow one to assess the case calmly. We tend
to say, “That will be a latissimus flap,” or “We’ll do an osteotomy
and a local flap here,” etc. When it comes to the actual operation, one
finds that one or two other things need to be done, and the whole procedure
may take up to an hour longer than envisaged. Patients at the end of the
day’s list may have to be postponed because time has run out.
- The Polaroid
photo will stay in the patient’s charts. Ideally, a postoperative Polaroid
should also be left in the notes.
- Some patients
may also be given their picture – which may be more important to them than
anything we will have done for them as surgeons
- A blue towel,
for use as a background against which the photos will be taken;
- Felt markers
(for drawing the patterns, and to write the patients’ names), a tape
measure;
- A pocket torch
for the examination of the inside of the nose, the mouth, etc.;
- Identity
badges for the team members, to enable patients and local personnel to know
who is who;
- Spare
batteries (for the cameras, examination lamps, etc.);
- Miscellaneous
items, as dictated by your specialty and your way of working.
For
surgery
- Case or bag
for carrying supplies;
- Sterile and
non-sterile gloves;
- Goggles;
- Operating
theatre wear: three cotton outfits, including overshoes or clogs, masks,
caps (we recommend cotton “bandanas”, which are better at soaking up
sweat running down the forehead), etc.;
- Sterilization
indicator tape;
- Surgical or
ordinary soap, nail brushes, etc.;
- Surgical
gowns. Disposable gowns are expensive and heavy to carry. Using locally
available coats is better.
- Consider
taking a headlight, with spare batteries (power cuts are a frequent
occurrence in some African hospitals);
- If possible,
take a sphygmomanometer with a manually inflatable cuff, which can be used
as a pneumatic tourniquet for hand surgery.
- Betadine,
Dakin (for skin disinfection prior to intraoperative injections); if
resources permit, include an HIV serology kit, post-exposure prophylaxis
kit, etc.
Consumables
- Betadine or
chlorhexidine, razors, felt markers or white pencil (for marking on very
dark skin), lignocaine with adrenaline, syringes and needles for
infiltration anaesthesia, scalpel blades, antibiotics, sterile drapes (which
are, however, expensive and, above all, bulky to carry; consider using
locally available drapes, which are, however, often worn and of poor
quality), absorbable sutures (do not forget Vicryl, which has the advantage
of rapid resorption in paediatric patients), nonabsorbable sutures, suckers,
suction drains and bottles (these items are bulky – the vacuum bottle may
be replaced by a syringe blocked in suction with a towel clip), sterile and
non-sterile swabs, tulle gras, adhesive dressings, adhesive tape, eye
ointment with and without antibiotics, antiseptics for use inside the mouth
(for maxillofacial surgery), analgesics for postoperative pain relief, etc.
Surgical
supplies
- Basic plastic
surgery set. At least three sets will be required, for the performance of
successive procedures. (Make sure you take your own sterilizaton indicator
tapes.)
- Special sets:
hand surgery set, with driver, pins, cement, etc., if a lot of upper limb
surgery is to be done on the mission. (Don’t forget to include a lead
hand, or similar device in a lighter material.) If there will be much facial
surgery (e.g. noma cases), take a maxillofacial surgery set with special
retractors, an appropriate saw (although the Gigli is still an excellent
tool), etc.
Personal
Check list
- Valid passport
and visa;
- Vaccination
certificates (as required for your destination);
- Photocopies
of documents
- Letter of
invitation by the local authorities (in countries with a military or
paramilitary system, a letter of this kind can ease travel and get you
through roadside check-points.);
- Personal
insurance (accident, return home, etc.) Consider paying your air ticket with
your bank card.
- Check that
your professional insurance covers your (professional) humanitarian work in
the foreign country. Ask for confirmation in writing.
- International
driving licence. For car hire, preferably go to an international company
(even if it costs more), rather than to a small local outfit. In some
countries, it is best to get a local driver.
- Personal
medicine chest: analgesics, antiseptics, antibiotics, spasmolytics,
intestinal antiseptics. Don’t forget a sunscreen and sun glasses, and a
mosquito repellent. Oral rehydration powders, which are rich in mineral
salts, are very useful and should be taken routinely while staying in
tropical countries.
- Personal
toilet items. If you are not going to stay at an hotel, take two
medium-sized towels (rather than one large one), plus two nails and a length
of line, to hang the towels from; a mosquito net (plus some nails to fix it
with); a mosquito spray; a small bottle of household bleach, for a spot of
cleaning around the place; etc.
- Usual clothing
(light cotton fabrics) for wear in tropical countries. Two points are worth
remembering: When going to Eastern European countries, take a jacket to wear
at official meetings; and in politically sensitive countries, do not strut
around in rough-tough “Gulf War” gear. In Africa, at so-called official
meetings, foreigners are not required to wear a jacket; however,
smart-casual wear will be a sign of respect towards your hosts.
- International
adapter with or without international Internet connection kit, if you
envisage using your laptop. (Bear in mind, though, that hardware can suffer
under conditions of heat and high humidity.)
- Small camera;
- Pocket torch;
- Wrist watch
with alarm function;
- Small DIY kit
(screw-driver, pliers, etc.), or a good Swiss army officer’s knife;
- Books, music,
other personal belongings, etc.;
- Local
currency;
- Small gifts
for children (balloons, ball-point pens, crayons, etc.)
While you
are out there
This is a
section in its own right; however, it has been left blank, since looking
forward to going, and imagining what it will be like, is better than being
told what it was like for someone else. To describe exactly what happens on a
mission would take away some of this anticipatory thrill.
Also, every
mission is unique. One cannot recount a mission. A mission is something that
one prepares for; something that one lives through (often only too briefly)
– it is not something that can be reconstituted afterwards in all its
details. Use your imagination to take you across from where you are now, to
that health centre far away.
Start dreaming
about your next mission right now.
When you are
back
After one’s
return, one cannot recount the entire trip, but there will be some stories and
some anecdotes to tell. The main evidence will consist of photographs.
Photographs will be all you have to show for your trip; their surgical scars
will be all that will remind the patients that you were once with them.
Debriefing is
essential, to enable the next mission to plan its work. We tend, increasingly,
to go back to the same country, so as to ensure the follow-up of our patients
and to provide continuity in the training of the local medical and paramedical
personnel. We are also beginning to provide the local team with digital
cameras, so that we can see the postoperative results, and can advise them,
via the Internet, on specific cases waiting to be seen on the next mission.
The analysis of
the series will often be complicated by the number of cases operated on, the
diversity of conditions seen, the different disease stages, the variety of
techniques used, the short follow-up, etc. However, publishing on this work
will ensure that we have to take an in-depth and self-critical look at what we
have been doing, and to ask ourselves whether we really have been as efficient
as we would like to think.
Practical
considerations
Before going on
a mission to a developing country, one would, first and foremost, try to find
out what conditions are likely to be encountered. However, a complete list of
all the usual and diverse conditions seen in tropical medicine would not
answer the questions of how one would cope out there, and how one would manage
one’s patients.
This article
attempts to provide practical answers, by describing six surgical techniques
which have allowed us to manage 86% of the patients encountered during
missions. The other conditions seen were treated with other established
reconstructive surgical techniques. This article does not aim to describe all
the surgical techniques available; rather, it lists and describes the most
useful and the most reliable ones.
From a
retrospective analysis of 100 patients operated on during humanitarian plastic
surgery missions, we have found the following six surgical techniques
to be particularly helpful:
- Z-plasties
(and similar operations), to provide lengthening: 32%;
- The Delaire
technique for the repair of labiomaxillary clefts, and for cleft-lip scar
revision: 26%;
- skin grafts:
14%;
- pedicled
pectoralis major flap: 9%;
- pedicled
latissimus dorsi flap: 4%; and
- pedicled groin
flap: 1%.
These
techniques have been used under sometimes difficult local conditions, and in
demanding cases. Their essential features – which must be shared by any
surgical technique to be used under difficult conditions – may be summed up
in the acronym FRED:
F for familiar:
the surgical procedure must be familiar to the surgeon. Doing something
familiar under difficult circumstances will be more likely to produce a good
result.
R for reliable
: a surgical technique must be reliable. A failed operation is nasty, for all
involved.
E for easy:
a surgical technique must be easy to teach. Mission work means transmission
work.
D for doable:
a surgical procedure must be feasible under challenging conditions and capable
of being performed single-handedly by one surgeon.
The surgical
techniques described in this article would seem to meet these requirements.
What
to do in practice
One of the
goals of reconstructive surgery is the reconstitution of the integrity of the
skin, by closing skin defects. If there are no defects, the surgeon will often
create one. Reconstructive surgery is a bit like robbing Peter to pay Paul:
one creates a defect in order to close another one; and then the artificially
created defect will need to be closed by the creation of yet another defect,
and so on.
There are
various ways of dealing with a skin defect. This article describes what
can be done, from the “simple” to the “most complex” ways of managing
defects.
From
the simple to the most complex
- Do nothing
(where conditions are unsuitable, one has to say no. The failure of an
operation that should not have been undertaken during a mission is
unpleasant and, above all, hardly justifiable.)
- controlled
healing by first intention;
- skin grafting;
- flaps.
Flaps
- local flaps
(lengthening);
- regional flaps
(pedicled flap from the same region – e.g. cross-finger flap);
- distant flaps,
which may be pedicled (e.g. groin flap) or free (e.g. microsurgically
anastomosed latissimus dorsi flap).
To finish with
these brief tips (which are, perhaps, best quickly forgotten), let us just
make the point that controlled secondary healing may be difficult, and a free
flap may, in some cases, be easier to perform. An inherently more complicated
technique may be the easier option. The advantage of a free flap (inherently a
very complex solution) is that several kinds of tissue can be reconstructed in
one go, and that, unlike some pedicled flaps, it does not involve several
sessions. Above all, any failure will be immediately obvious, and the patient
may be appropriately revised. A pedicled flap may look great straight after
surgery, but may undergo secondary necrosis. Impaired blood supply may be less
obvious in dark skin, and the surgeon may have gone happily home by the time
the flap has gone, unhappily, bad.
The
Techniques
Skin
lengthening
Indications
If the range of
plastic surgery techniques had to be reduced to a single one, the choice would
be the Z-plasty. Quite generally, anything that will permit length to be
gained in a flat surface scar or a webbed scar has a place in humanitarian
plastic surgery. We often have to deal with patients with burn scars, who will
have contracted skin. These contractures may be anywhere on the body. They may
be dramatic around the joints, and will benefit enormously from being
released. Contractures may be post-traumatic (especially in the limbs), caused
by infections, or secondary to such tropical conditions as noma (especially
affecting the face).
Principles
Surgical
procedures in this category are designed to increase the length of the skin.
They allow a gain in length in the case of a flat surface scar or of a webbed
scar.
The principle consists in making incisions in a scar or scar band, and
bringing in healthy skin from the sides in order to lengthen the contractural
line and, thus, to release the tension caused by the contracture.
Lengthening flaps come in different patterns. For a Z-plasty, two
interdigitating triangular flaps are arranged in a Z-pattern; for a V-Y flap,
a V-shaped incision is converted into a Y pattern; etc.
Some of the
patterns shown in the textbooks are quite complex, although, mathematically,
they are extremely sound. However, their execution may be well-nigh
impossible, and the actual results may fall far short of the underlying
calculations. The skin is, however, a forgiving tissue, and allows the surgeon
a considerable amount of leeway. What is important is the careful marking of
the adjoining healthy skin that can be brought in to provide the gain in
length. Tracing the geometrical pattern is often useful; however, what matters
even more is a careful palpation of the zone surrounding the scar to establish
where tissue can best be mobilized. The operative word in plastic surgery is
“plastic.”
In the descriptions below, the conventional rules have been boiled down to two
types of skin-lengthening surgery:
- advancement
flaps, in which the skin is undermined and advanced (as in a V-Y flap);
and
- pivotal
flaps, in which the flap is raised and turned into the defect. Pivotal
flaps come as rotation flaps, transposition flaps, IC-flaps, etc. However,
regardless of the actual pattern, the principle remains the same: the flap
is pivoted into the defect. A Z-plasty, for instance, involves the
simultaneous transposition of the two flaps that have been raised.
Whatever the
design used, these flaps will invariably be what is known as random-pattern
flaps, since they are not supplied by a named artery. This is why the length
of the flap has to be chosen with care: it must not be greater than twice the
width of the flap at its base. This 2:1 rule is not, however, an absolute one.
In a well-vascularized territory such as the face, a ratio of 3:1 may be
acceptable, while in an extensive scar bed a flap of equal length and base
width may have to be used.
| Simple
advancement flap for the management of a web space contracture |
 |

 |
| Simple
advancement flap (top). Where more tissue has to be advanced, skin
traction will produce “dog-ears” on either side of the flap base.
These can be excised, and the suture line adjusted accordingly
(bottom). |
The
repair pattern comprises an advancement flap and two small rotation
flaps. |
| V-Y
advancement flap |
 |
| Basic
pattern
The
skin incision forms a V.
Skin traction transforms the V- into a Y-shape, allowing a length
gain.
|
| V-Y
advancement flap |
  |
| Y-V
repair of a thumb–index web space contracture (flap 5), combined
with small transposition flaps (flaps 1 through 4)
The
first incision is Y-shaped. Advancement of Flap 5 converts the Y into
a V, allowing lengthening of the scar. To further improve lengthening,
transposition flaps (Flaps 1 and 2; Flaps 3 and 4) are added on either
side, in a Z-plasty pattern.
Treatment
of several scar bands of the web spaces and the wrist (post accidental
burn) using Y-V advancement and Z-plasties.
|
| Transposition
graft (Z-plasty) |
 |
Basic
pattern of Z-plasty
The
basic pattern is a Z with limbs of equal length, with the peripheral
limbs forming an angle of ca. 60° with the central limb. The size of
the angle is not an absolute figure, and may be varied, as a function
of the skin site, between 30° and 90°. Theoretically, the greater
the angle the more the scar will be lengthened. The central limb of
the Z is placed over the surface scar to be lengthened or the webbed
scar to be corrected. After this line has been drawn, the peripheral
limbs are added, to form two equilateral triangles (top).
If the conditions have been chosen correctly, incision of the skin
over the central limb will pull and transpose the triangles into their
new position (centre).
The final pattern shows how the flaps have been transposed, to form a
“mirror-image” Z. The skin has been “relaxed” along the line
of the old scar (bottom). |


Repair of plantar ulcer with a simple plantar rotation flap.
 
Treatment of an oral commissure contracture using a Z-plasty.
  
Burn scars with a bowstring scar band on the fold of the left axilla,
interfering with abduction. The band is divided, and the axillary defect is
covered with a cutaneous rotation flap. The skin flap is raised in the
parascapular region, and rotated into the ipsilateral axillary area.
Skin
grafts
Indications
Patients seen
during humanitarian missions usually present with old scars. If the defect
that has to be created in the revision is large, or if there are other reasons
that rule out the use of local flaps, skin grafts will be indicated. Both
full-thickness skin grafts and split-thickness skin grafts are of enormous
benefit. Skin grafting is often thought to be a simple procedure. It is, in
fact, complex surgery, and must be treated as such. All too often, surgeons
will do a flap reconstruction because they believe that a mere skin graft
would be too mundane. When repairing a defect, one should always start by
considering the simplest solution, and opt for a more complex one only if
absolutely necessary.Skin grafts are “simple” in principle, but highly
complex in their details.Where an extensive defect needs to be covered, and/or
where the granulation tissue is of poor quality, a split-thickness skin graft
is indicated. Greater coverage may be obtained by meshing a split-thickness
skin graft. A split-thickness skin graft will take better, but will contract
over time.Conversely, if the defect has a good base (well-vascularized zone,
or good granulation tissue) and/or where it is vital that the graft should not
contract secondarily (grafts placed around joints or body openings), a
full-thickness skin graft should be chosen.
| Split-thickness
skin graft |
 |
| -
Patient positioning. The patient is positioned supine. The graft is
harvested from the medial and/or the anterior aspect of the thigh. The
donor area is lubricated by wiping with tulle gras. The surgeon places
one hand underneath the patient’s thigh, and “pinches” the skin
on the posterior aspect, so as to tighten the skin on the front of the
thigh. With his or her other hand, the surgeon cuts the graft using a
manual dermatome.
- The
chief problem in split-thickness skin graft cutting is judging the
thickness of the graft. With practice, setting the knife will enable
the surgeon to choose the graft thickness. At the start of the
learning curve, however, it may be difficult to control the thickness
of the graft. If, during harvesting, fat or, worse, muscle is exposed,
the cut will be too deep. If the graft looks like tissue paper and
tends to tear, the cut will be too shallow. Ideally, there should be a
high density of tiny bleeding points on a white ground. This bleeding
pattern indicates that the cut is in the correct plane (the dermis).
When the graft has been cut, the donor area will bleed, and should be
managed immediately by the application of a slightly compressive tulle
gras dressing.
|
Exemple

Buruli ulcer of the anterior aspect of the foot, in a young man from Benin.
Excision of the ulcer had left a large defect, which was resurfaced with a
split-thickness skin graft harvested, with a manual dermatome, from the
ipsilateral thigh.
Skin grafts
  
Extensive burns of the lower limb. Debridement and coverage by a
split-thickness skin graft. The size of the defect called for a mesh graft,
produced by harvesting split-thickness skin grafts and meshing them, using a
skin graft expander to allow a larger surface to be covered.
Full-thickness skin graft
Donor sites
 
Harvesting a full-thickness skin graft
 
A full-thickness skin graft comprises all the layers of the skin. Its size
will need to match that of the defect to be repaired. Its texture should
match that of the recipient area. Harvesting must be done in such a way as
to allow simple closure of the donor site.
Full-thickness skin graft preparation

Defatting the graft is vital, and has to be done with meticulous
care. This is the most important step in the technique. Any tiny lobule left
behind will prevent blood vessels to sprout into the graft at that site.
Trimming has to be carried out tangentially to the skin, until shiny dermis
is seen everywhere. Overzealous trimming may result in buttonholing;
however, this is nothing to worry about. A few little nicks are better than
having fat remaining on the underside of the graft.
The poorer
the recipient bed, the more thoroughly the graft will need to be defatted.
However, the more fat has been removed, the thinner, and hence more liable
to shrink, the graft will be.
Conversely,
where the graft bed is sound, a full-thickness skin graft will take more
readily. Under these circumstances, it will not be necessary to thin the
graft out too much, and the slightly thicker graft will not shrink
secondarily.
In practice,
a commissural defect in a child is ideally suited for grafting with
full-thickness skin: the site offers a good base, the graft is flexible and
will not shrink, and the child will not, therefore, be at risk from
secondary contracture around the body opening.
Applying a tie-over bolster dressing
 
A freshly placed full-thickness skin graft will be kept alive, initially, by
the fluid provided through the moist dressings applied by the surgeon. Since
the graft will be colonized from its base, care must be taken to ensure that
it does not move and that it stays firmly applied to the graft bed. This can
be done by using a tie-over bolster dressing. The graft is sutured into
place, with the sutures left long. Next, it is covered with a layer of tulle
gras, on top of which is placed a flat piece of well-soaked gauze. The
bolster is carefully moulded into position over the graft. The sutures are
tied, and the dressing is left in situ for three days. When it comes to the
removal of the dressing, great care must be taken not to lift the graft off
with the bolster.
Tie-over
dressings are vital in concavities. The pressure dressing snugs the graft
into its concave bed. Where the graft bed is convex, a skin graft will be
more liable to stay in place, and a tie-over dressing is not an absolute
necessity.
Patient Example

This Congolese patient had burn scars of the right hand that had completely
obliterated the web spaces. The webs were reconstructed, with close
attention to the neurovascular and tendinous structures, and the defects
were covered with full-thickness skin grafts.
The
Delaire technique for the repair of cleft lip
Indications
Congenital
cleft lip and/or palate is a condition frequently encountered on humanitarian
missions. Also, patients often present with previously operated-on clefts
which have caused functional and/or cosmetic problems. Contrary to what one
might expect, the patients’ parents are chiefly concerned about the
children’s appearance. In some countries, the congenital malformation is
attributed to the influence of evil spirits. In such cases, cosmetic repair
may be important, the involvement of the local “healer” may also be very
helpful. In the popular language, such malformations are still known as
“hare-lip”, even in our parts of the world – which goes to show that
beliefs may be much more resistant than some hospital bugs.While, as pointed
out above, surgeons would be well advised to bear these beliefs in mind, their
goal will also be to restore good function, by achieving a normal force
pattern of the nasolabial muscles. Reapproximating the muscles in the midline
will ensure balanced growth of the face. In cleft lip, there is not a defect
in the strict sense of the word. What has happened is that midline muscle
fusion has failed to occur at the embryonic stage. The whole thing is like a
sail with a slack sheet, which blows away with the wind. Surgery is aimed at
reapproximating the muscles in the midline, just as a yachtsman would haul the
sheet taut in order to make headway.
Principles
This repair
involves a number of steps.
- Tracing the
incisions of the mucocutaneous elements. The pattern follows the rules
established by J. Delaire, in his excellent and very practical technique.
The technique itself is an adaptation of the one devised by R. Millard
(large rotation-advancement flap). Identifying the muscles on either
side of the cleft and at the base of the septum, to which the muscles will
be attached.Release of the nasolabial muscles from their deep
insertions on the maxilla, to facilitate medial displacement and
tension-free suturing to the nasal septum, to the periosteum of the nasal
spine, and to the muscular counterparts on the noncleft side.
- Reapproximation
of the tissue planes of the mucous membranes, the muscles, and the skin,
using fine sutures.
| Landmarks |
 |
| This
schematic may look like a bewildering jumble of dots and figures.
Don’t worry. All surgical techniques have got their difficult bits.
With this technique, the crucial learning step is to spend 15 minutes
looking at the landmarks. You will then know how to apply them first
time round; and after that, they will become second nature.
For
true mastery of the craft of cleft-lip repair, one needs to control,
and then to forget, the technical aspects. Just do it – and
experience the fulfilment that comes from giving a little kid a pretty
lip.
Take
heart – it’s not as difficult as you might think!
a:
Superior nostril angle on the noncleft side.
a’: Superior nostril angle on the cleft side.
b: Base of columella on the noncleft side.
c: Lowest point in arch of Cupid’s bow, at the vermilion-cutaneous
junction.
d: Peak of Cupid’s bow, at the vermilion-cutaneous junction, on the
noncleft side.
e: Extremity of the vermilion-cutaneous roll on the cleft side.
1: Point situated on a line extending from the edge of the columella
on the cleft side, at a distance from a’ equal to b–a.
2: Point situated on a line extending the line b–1, at the
vermilion-cutaneous junction.
3: Point at the vermilion-cutaneous junction on the cleft side, at a
distance from c equal to d–c.
4: Point situated on the moist-dry line, at a distance from the
frenulum (midline) of the upper lip equal to c–3.
5: Point situated at the junction of the nasal ala and the lip, on the
cleft side.
6: Point situated on the vermilion-cutaneous junction, on the line
5–6, which is at right angles to the vermilion-cutaneous junction.
7: Point situated where the vermilion-cutaneous roll begins to taper
(ca. 2–3 mm lateral to e).
8: Point situated on the moist-dry line opposite Point 7.
|
| Incisions
of the mucocutaneous elements |
 |
| The
mucocutaneous elements are incised as shown in the schematic.
We
recommend a small lateral triangle above the vermilion-cutaneous roll
if the skin is badly retracted and the roll is not very pronounced.
The size of the triangle will be a function of the difference in
height between the cleft and the noncleft side.
|
| Tracing
the muscles |
  |
1:
Schematic representation of the transverse nasal muscle.
2: Schematic representation of the levator labii superioris alaeque
nasi muscle.
2': Schematic representation of the levator labii superioris muscle.
3: Cartilaginous septum.
4: Lower end of transverse nasal muscle exposed during dissection.
5: Marginal part of orbicularis oris muscle.
6: Depressor septi nasi muscle.
7: Labial part of orbicularis oris muscle. |
| Release
of nasolabial muscles |
 |
|
This
release is performed in the subperiosteal plane, from the nasal bone
and the infraorbital margin (below the infraorbital foramen) to the
zygomatic process of the maxilla. |
| Suturing
the mucocutaneous elements |
  |
In
conclusion, we recommend
- treating an incomplete unilateral cleft like a complete cleft;
- treating a bilateral cleft using the same principles as those
described for the management of a unilateral cleft, and applying these
principles to both clefts. It must, however, be borne in mind that the
prolabium is devoid of muscles. |
PATIENT
EXAMPLES

Naso-labio-palatine residual deformities in a young Indian girl who had been
operated on in childhood, for left-sided cleft lip and palate. Before and
after a Delaire revision.

Right-sided cleft lip in a child from Togo (Interplast-France mission).
Before and after a Delaire repair. The Delaire is a modification of the
Millard technique (large rotation-advancement flap).
The
pedicled pectoralis major flap
Indications
The main
indication for this flap, in surgical mission practice, is facial
reconstructive surgery. In the management of trauma, cancer, and the sequelae
of cancrum oris (noma), the pectoralis major flap has proved to be a reliable
means of bringing skin and muscle to a facial site. When tunneled
subcutaneously, it will produce minimal scarring on the front of the chest,
which is important in Africa, where keloid formation is common. The skin
paddle may be harvested in the inframammary fold, so as to produce even fewer
visible scars. The flap is raised on a pedicle, which needs to be “slid”
to its destination, underneath the skin of the neck and the face (in the plane
used for face lifts). Some surgeons bring the pedicle to the outside, so as to
reduce compression on the tissue and thus to improve its chance of survival.
The procedure is comparatively easy to teach, but requires good visualization
of the pedicle during surgery, and, therefore, good lighting. (This may be a
problem in some theatres; also, remember to take a pocket torch, so as to have
a light source in the event of a power cut.)
| Principles:
Flap pattern and landmarks |
 |
| The
patient is positioned supine.
To find
the course of the main vascular pedicle, draw a line from the acromion
to the xiphoid process. Next, draw a line a right angles to the first
line, starting from the mid-point of the clavicle. However, the true
course of the vascular pedicle can be established only at surgery,
when the skin paddle has been raised and the underside of pectoralis
major has been reached. At this stage, the course of the vessel can be
established with certainty, and the incisions on either side of the
intended pedicle can be determined more accurately.
|
| Flap
dissection |
 |
| After
the raising of the skin paddle, the lower border of the muscle is
identified, and the space underneath the muscle is entered. Blunt
finger dissection is readily performed between the muscle and the rib
cage. The vascular pedicle must be identified on the undersurface of
the muscle. The anterior aspect of the muscle is dissected free;
working in this plane is very straightforward. |
| Dissection
of the pedicle |
 |
| Once the
axial pattern has been determined, the muscle is incised on either
side, to form a strip all the way up to the clavicle (which is the
pivot point). The strip is brought out through a skin incision made
along the clavicle. |
| Tunneling
the flap |
 |
| The flap
is taken through beneath the skin of the neck and the face, to its
intended site in the face. Care must be taken to avoid pedicle
compression by too narrow a tunnel. |
| Arc
of rotation of a pectoralis major flap |
 |
PATIENT
EXAMPLE

Young girl from Togo, with facial sequelae of noma. The cheek defect was
reconstructed using a pedicled myocutaneous pectoralis major flap (Interplast-France
mission).
The
pedicled latissimus dorsi flap
Indications
The latissimus
dorsi flap, in its pedicled form, is very reliable and has a long “reach”.
It can be used to transfer a considerable amount of muscle and skin. It can
reach the face; however, in order to get there, its pedicle may
“bowstring”, and considerable subcutaneous dissection may be required in
order to take it to its destination without causing contracture. Reaching the
anterior aspect of the chest, the upper abdomen, the back, and the upper limb
(to the level of the elbow) is also straightforward.As a free flap (with
microsurgical anastomosis), it can be done, even under challenging conditions,
using magnifying loupes (x3.5). The free flap has the advantage of allowing a
customized transfer of different tissues; however, it also has the
disadvantages inherent in any microsurgical procedure, especially since the
result will be less predictable in sickle cell anaemia patients (since free
flaps are not very tolerant of tissue anoxia).
Principles
The latissimus
dorsi flap may be muscular or myocutaneous. The principles of harvesting are
the same. However, for the myocutaneous flap, the muscle has to be harvested
with an overlying skin paddle.
| Patient
positioning |
 |
| The
patient is positioned supine, with a rolled towel under the shoulder
and the buttock. The arm may be included in the operative field, or
placed on an armboard. The axilla must be fully accessible, to allow
dissection of the throacodorsal vascular pedicle.
The
drawing shows a myocutaneous latissimus dorsi flap, with the skin
paddle outlined.
|
| Dissection
of the flap |
 |
| The
incision is made over the anterior border of the latissimus dorsi
muscle. The border is identified, and the anterior aspect of the
muscle is exposed. Detachment by finger dissection is straightforward,
and allows the vascular supply of the muscle coursing beneath the
fascia to be displayed. |
| Division
of the muscle |
 |
| Once the
vascular pedicle has been identified, the muscle may be divided, to
produce an axial-pattern flap.
The
deeper layer in the drawing shows the supply to the serratus anterior
muscle, which, if required, may be harvested at the same time as the
latissimus dorsi flap.
|
| Dissection
of the pedicle |
 |
| For
maximal flap mobilization, dissection of the pedicle should be carried
as high up as possible.
The
vascular pedicle to serratus anterior is ligated. The drawing shows
the supply to latissimus dorsi and serratus anterior to come from a
common trunk.
For
greater ease of flap mobilization, the tendinous insertion on the
humerus may be divided.
|
| Arc
of rotation of a latissimus dorsi flap |
 |
PATIENT
EXAMPLE

Young Nigerian male, with burn scars of the right elbow. After elbow
release, the defect was covered with an ipsilateral myocutaneous latissimus
dorsi flap.
PATIENT EXAMPLE

Man from northern Togo (Afagnan), with a large abdominal tumour. Defect
repair required an ipsilateral pedicled latissimus dorsi flap
The
pedicled groin flap
Indications
Knowing this
flap is essential. Together with the Z-plasty and the latissimus dorsi flap,
it is “the” technique that any surgeon must master. It constitutes a
reliable means of covering defects in the hand and the forearm, even if there
is local infection. However, it does require a second operation for the
detachment of the pedicle. This operation, which is performed between two and
three weeks after the first session, can be readily explained to the local
team, who will need to do the release. We would, however, recommend that these
flaps be scheduled early on during the mission, so as to enable the visiting
surgeon to perform the release before his or her return home.
| Principles:
Patient positioning |
 |
| Supine,
with a small towel under the ipsilateral buttock. The skin paddle is
designed over the vascular pedicle. |
| Landmarks |
 |
| Landmarks:
1)
Superficial circumflex iliac artery. This vessel comes off the femoral
artery, 1 to 3 cm below the inguinal ligament.
2) Superficial epigastric artery.
3) Anterior superior iliac spine (ASIS).
4) Pubic tubercle.
In
practice, a line can be drawn from the ASIS to the pubic tubercle. One
third of the skin paddle should be drawn above this line, and two
thirds below.
|
| Dissection
of the groin flap |
 |
| Dissection
is started at the distal end of the skin paddle, since that makes it
easier to find the plane of dissection over the aponeurosis. Next, the
dissection should be taken underneath the sartorius fascia, so as to
keep the vascular pedicle in the flap. Also, the dissection should
stop short of the femoral artery, so as not to sever the vascular
pedicle of the flap. |
| Tubing
the groin flap |
 |
| Tubing:
This is done to fashion the bridge segment into a “trunk” - and
idea that goes down very well in Africa. This pedicle allows better
mobilization of the hand, and makes dressing easier. However, the
patient, his or her family, and the paramedical staff may find this
technique slightly disconcerting, and will need lots of explanations. |
| Dressing |
 |
| We feel
that there is no need for a special dressing, and prefer to leave the
arm exposed. All that is required is to explain to the patient (and
the nursing staff) that the whole thing is “sound” and will not
“pull out” while the patient is asleep. The patient must be
reassured that the sutures will hold. We have given up using
complicated bandages on the arm and the hand. We do not recommend
stout sutures between the skin of the abdomen and the hand, to relieve
any tension by the hand on the sutures. The best immobilization is an
explanation of the procedure and of the “construct”. We do,
however, use a small dressing to allow the wrist, the elbow, and the
shoulder to be mobilized daily. We still remember the patient who,
frightened by the operation, had kept her arm “still” for a
fortnight. By the end of that time, her nails were dug into the skin
of the abdomen, and her shoulder had gone stiff. |
PTIENT EXAMPLE

Young woman from Togo, with sequelae of infection of the dorsum of the right
wrist. As a child, she had had an injury treated by the application of
“herbs” by a local healer; this had led to major infection of the local
tissues. She had since grown up with the back of her wrist “stuck”
against her forearm. We excised the scar band on the dorsum of the wrist and
performed joint release. The defect on the dorsum was covered with an
ipsilateral groin flap.
CONCLUSION
Plastic
surgery under challenging conditions means doing reconstructive surgery
under difficult circumstances, in developing countries. All aspects of plastic
surgery come into this work, and surgeons going on missions will need a fairly
comprehensive knowledge of the discipline.Having been on a number of surgical
missions, we feel that certain techniques are particularly useful. They
obviously cannot solve all the problems encountered, but have allowed us to
treat the majority of the patients seen on missions. Any surgeon intending to
go on a mission should, therefore, be conversant with the Z-plasty, skin
grafting, the pectoralis major flap, the latissimus dorsi flap, and the groin
flap.Plastic surgery travels well and can be practised under all manner of
circumstances. Surgical missions involve a visiting team working closely
together with all the local health care professionals. The ultimate purpose of
this cooperation is the training of the local staffs.Any surgeon working on a
mission will receive as much as he or she gives. Often, one may feel that what
one has to give is so little, seeing how many patients there are to be
treated. But remember: the little that remains goes far beyond the things that
pass.
|